News Center
News Center
Image Name

NEWS

News Center

Discussion on Anti-Corrosion Technologies for Seawater Heat Exchangers

2014-09-24 10:25

  Corrosion is a pervasive issue across all sectors and industries, posing significant threats to national economic development, human well-being, and the environment. Corrosion often leads to shortened plant operating cycles, premature failure of equipment and facilities, reduced service life, and environmental pollution; it also hinders the smooth advancement of new technologies. According to statistics, annual economic losses attributable to corrosion in various countries typically range from 1% to 5% of their respective GDPs, varying with each country’s level of economic development and corrosion‑control capabilities. In China, the economic impact of corrosion is particularly severe: according to data from the “China Corrosion Survey Report,” the country’s annual corrosion‑related losses have recently amounted to approximately RMB 500 billion.

  Seawater heat exchangers are among the most widely used and critical pieces of equipment in ship operations and offshore platforms. The performance of these heat exchangers directly affects the overall stable operation and key economic indicators of vessels and production platforms, playing a vital role in ensuring safe, reliable, and long‑term system performance. Seawater contains high concentrations of dissolved oxygen, chloride ions, and microorganisms, which exert severe corrosive effects on metallic heat exchangers. As is well known, the marine environment constitutes a highly complex and extremely harsh corrosion milieu. In this setting, the atmosphere primarily comprises water vapor, oxygen, nitrogen, carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, and suspended chlorides, sulfates, and other salts. It is characterized by higher humidity, elevated salinity, elevated temperatures, and pronounced dry–wet cycling effects, all of which significantly enhance its corrosive potential toward metals.

  1. Common Corrosion Mechanisms in Marine Environments

  1.1 Electrochemical Corrosion

  Electrochemical corrosion is the most common and widespread form of corrosion; it may occur alone or in conjunction with mechanical factors. In electrolyte solutions—such as water—carbon steel forms micro‑batteries. The primary microstructural constituents of carbon steel are ferrite (Fe) and cementite (Fe₃C). In an electrolyte, this gives rise to a galvanic cell in which the lower‑potential ferrite serves as the anode and the higher‑potential cementite acts as the cathode, leading to the corrosion of the steel.

  Anode: 2Fe → 2Fe²⁺ + 4e⁻

  Meanwhile, electrons flow from the anode to the cathode, where oxygen in the water combines with the electrons to form hydroxide ions.

  Cathode: 4e⁻ + 2H₂O + O₂ → 4OH⁻

  In the solution, Fe²⁺ reacts with OH⁻ to form Fe(OH)₂, which precipitates near the interface between the anode and cathode.

  Overall reaction equation: 2Fe + O₂ + 2H₂O → 2Fe(OH)₂

  It is oxidized by atmospheric oxygen to form iron(III) hydroxide: 4Fe(OH)₂ + O₂ + 2H₂O = 4Fe(OH)₃↓

  In this way, rust forms on the steel.

  1.2 Chloride Ion Corrosion

  Seawater, one of the media used in marine metal heat exchangers, contains a high concentration of chloride ions and exhibits strong corrosivity. The primary types of corrosion it induces in stainless steel heat exchangers are stress corrosion and pitting corrosion.

  (1) In seawater, chloride ions degrade the passive film on metal heat exchangers (stainless steel) used in ships and offshore platforms. Under tensile stress, the areas where the passive film has been compromised develop cracks, becoming anodic regions of a corrosion cell. Continuous electrochemical corrosion can ultimately lead to material failure. This type of corrosion is relatively insensitive to chloride ion concentration; even trace amounts of chloride ions can trigger stress corrosion.

  (2) In seawater, chloride ions readily adsorb onto the passivation film of heat exchangers, displacing oxygen atoms and subsequently combining with cations in the film to form soluble chlorides. This process leads to localized corrosion—small pits—on the exposed metal surfaces of the heat exchanger; these pits are referred to as pitting nuclei. The resulting chlorides are prone to hydrolysis, lowering the pH within the pits and rendering the solution acidic. This acidification dissolves a portion of the oxide film, releasing excess metal ions. To maintain electrical neutrality within the pit, chloride ions from the surrounding environment continuously migrate inward, further promoting hydrolysis of the metal inside the pit. This cyclical process causes austenitic stainless steel to corrode progressively faster, with the corrosion advancing deeper into the pit until perforation occurs, ultimately leading to pitting corrosion.

  1.3 Atmospheric Corrosion

  Marine atmosphere refers to the atmospheric zone above the sea-spray region and the coastal atmospheric zone. This region primarily contains water vapor, oxygen, nitrogen, carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, as well as suspended chloride and sulfate particles. It is characterized by higher humidity, elevated salt content, elevated temperature, and a pronounced dry–wet cycling effect compared with ordinary atmospheres. Due to its high humidity, water vapor—under the influence of capillary action, adsorption, and chemical condensation—adsorbs onto steel surfaces, forming an invisible thin water film. In this film, CO2, SO2, and certain salts dissolve, creating a highly conductive electrolyte solution. Because the standard electrode potentials of iron, the principal constituent of steel, and trace elements such as carbon differ, when these metals coexist in the electrolyte solution (the water film), numerous galvanic cells are established. Iron, acting as the anode, undergoes oxidation in the electrolyte (the water film), losing electrons and transforming into iron oxide—rust.

  Due to the relatively high relative humidity of the marine atmospheric environment, the water film is thicker and has a higher salt content, resulting in stronger electrolytic activity. Moreover, in this environment, steel structures exposed to sunlight during the day experience evaporation that increases surface salinity, while at night a moist surface forms. This alternating dry–wet cycle significantly accelerates corrosion. In addition, other dissolved substances in the water film—such as oxygen, carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, and various chlorides and sulfates—deposit on the steel surface. On one hand, salts dissolve in the water film, and carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide render it acidic, thereby enhancing its electrical conductivity; on the other hand, chloride ions exhibit penetrating action, promoting localized corrosion mechanisms such as pitting, stress corrosion, intergranular corrosion, and crevice corrosion. Consequently, the marine atmospheric corrosion environment is far more severe than that of inland atmospheres.

  2. Anti-corrosion Measures

  Due to variations in the operating conditions of heat exchangers—such as temperature, pressure, fluid type, and flow velocity—the materials selected and the structural design differ, leading to distinct predominant forms of corrosion failure on the heat-transfer surfaces. Consequently, the corresponding corrosion‑prevention strategies also vary, resulting in a diverse and complex array of surface‑treatment techniques. Nevertheless, most corrosion‑control approaches can be grouped under three fundamental principles: (1) isolating the metal surface from the service environment; (2) modifying the environment to keep anodic or cathodic reactions within a controllable range; and (3) employing highly corrosion‑resistant metallic or nonmetallic materials. To date, both domestically and internationally, the principal surface‑protection technologies for heat exchangers include: (1) applying corrosion‑resistant coatings; (2) implementing electrochemical protection; (3) adding corrosion inhibitors; (4) depositing corrosion‑resistant diffusion layers; and (5) adopting integrated treatment methods.

  2.1 Selection of Corrosion-Resistant Materials

  Material selection for corrosion resistance is the primary principle in heat exchanger corrosion‑protection design. To achieve corrosion resistance, heat exchangers should, during both design and fabrication, prioritize the use of corrosion‑resistant materials in place of ordinary carbon steel. Currently, highly corrosion‑resistant heat exchangers include stainless steel units, titanium and titanium alloy heat exchangers, graphite heat exchangers, glass‑lined heat exchangers, plastic‑based heat exchangers, and ceramic heat exchangers. In marine refrigeration equipment, aluminum bronze and nickel‑silver are commonly employed for heat exchange tubes; end caps exposed to seawater are typically cast from aluminum bronze or plastic, while tube sheets in contact with seawater are made of stainless steel. Composite tube sheets combining aluminum bronze or plastic with carbon steel are also utilized. For heat exchangers installed on offshore oil and gas drilling platforms operating in CO₂‑containing fluids, chromium‑alloyed stainless steels exhibit good corrosion resistance. However, when the fluid also contains hydrogen sulfide and chlorides, caution is required due to susceptibility to sulfide‑induced stress cracking and chloride‑induced stress cracking; such grades are generally not recommended. By contrast, duplex stainless steels containing 22%–25% chromium and high‑nickel austenitic stainless steels demonstrate excellent corrosion resistance under high‑temperature, high‑chloride conditions and can effectively resist hydrogen sulfide‑induced stress corrosion.

  2.2 Application of Corrosion-Resistant Coatings

  Corrosion‑resistant coatings not only impart to heat‑transfer surfaces resistance to erosion, permeation, and moisture‑induced degradation, but also isolate the metal surface from the process fluid and inhibit scale formation. To a certain extent, they can enhance the performance and service life of heat exchangers. However, this approach faces two key challenges: coating‑material performance and application‑process issues. In seawater and brine‑service heat exchangers, zinc‑rich coatings and epoxy‑based coatings are widely employed. Although significant progress has been made in applying corrosion‑resistant coatings to heat exchangers, further refinement and optimization remain essential. The development of such coatings should aim for low cost, environmental friendliness, and high performance. Moreover, careful attention must be paid to the rational design of the heat exchanger’s geometry, as an appropriately engineered structure plays a critical role in simplifying the coating‑application process and improving coating quality.

  2.3 Protection by Diffusion-Plated Corrosion-Resistant Coating

  Diffusion plating is a surface‑treatment process in which a gaseous, solid, or molten substance—typically a metal or nonmetal element—is introduced into the surface of a base metal by diffusion at elevated temperatures, thereby forming an alloyed surface layer. The resulting coating is called a diffusion‑plated layer and is used to enhance properties such as oxidation (corrosion) resistance, heat resistance, and wear resistance. Aluminum diffusion is one of the most commonly employed diffusion‑plating techniques; the diffusing element is aluminum, which improves the high‑temperature oxidation resistance and gas‑corrosion resistance of steels, nonferrous metals, and alloys, while also providing excellent corrosion resistance in atmospheres, hydrogen sulfide, carbon dioxide, and seawater. Aluminum‑diffusion processes have been widely adopted in industries such as oil refining, metallurgy, and chemical engineering. Compared with aluminum diffusion, zinc diffusion offers several advantages: the process operates at relatively lower temperatures, around 400–500°C, reducing the risk of deformation in heat exchangers; it not only enhances the corrosion resistance of metallic materials in atmospheric conditions, water, hydrogen sulfide, and certain organic media but also imparts higher hardness and wear resistance to the component’s surface than either electroplated or hot‑dip galvanized coatings; the diffusion layer is remarkably uniform, and when treating parts with complex geometries, the zinc‑diffused layer exhibits distinct benefits—its thickness remains nearly consistent across threads, internal surfaces, grooves, and other features. Moreover, the zinc‑diffused layer forms a metallurgical bond with the substrate, making delamination highly unlikely. Additionally, the potential difference between the zinc‑diffused layer and the base metal is smaller than that between zinc and iron, giving the zinc‑diffused layer superior protective performance as an anodic barrier. It is generally accepted that thicker zinc‑diffused layers provide greater corrosion resistance. Zinc‑diffused products have been progressively introduced across diverse industrial sectors, including petroleum, chemicals, power generation, machinery, water resources, marine engineering, telecommunications, construction, mining, and transportation. Electroless nickel‑phosphorus plating is a chemical treatment method that uses a reducing agent to selectively reduce nickel ions in solution, depositing them onto catalytically activated surfaces to form a metallic coating. Because the electroless nickel‑phosphorus coating is an amorphous alloy—akin to metallic glass—it exhibits exceptional corrosion resistance (e.g., against H₂S and Cl⁻), outstanding high‑temperature stability (operable continuously up to 380°C), resistance to erosion and abrasion (with appreciable hardness), good thermal conductivity, and effective anti‑scaling properties. Consequently, heat exchangers coated with electroless nickel‑phosphorus are increasingly favored by petrochemical enterprises and can serve as protective linings for offshore platform heat exchangers.

  2.4 Enamel Protection

  Enamel is a vitreous coating formed by applying, under high‑temperature conditions and via the enameling process, non‑metallic organic materials onto a metallic substrate. This results in a product in which the enamel layer is tightly bonded to the metal, combining the strength and rigidity of metals with the aesthetic appeal, smoothness, and corrosion resistance characteristic of non‑metallic inorganic materials. Process‑type enamel employs enamel‑making techniques to integrate acid‑resistant glassy materials—possessing the properties of industrial glass—onto metallic substrates, yielding a glass–metal composite. The resulting coating exhibits the superior properties of acid‑resistant glass, including exceptional corrosion resistance, high chemical stability, and a dense, non‑porous structure, while also being free of metallic ions—advantages that set it apart from other types of enamel. In industrial applications, this type of enamel is referred to as “enamelled glass.” Products include enameled glass vessels and enameled heat exchangers, which are manufactured by repeatedly firing a high‑silica enamel glaze at temperatures around 900°C, ensuring strong adhesion between the glaze and the metal surface. The typical thickness of the enamel layer ranges from 0.8 to 1.5 mm. Thanks to the protective barrier provided by the glass layer, enameled glass vessels and heat exchangers exhibit excellent corrosion resistance. For heat exchangers that use seawater as the working fluid, applying an enamel coating to the inner surfaces of the shell, end caps, and tube sheets effectively prevents seawater‑induced corrosion.

  2.5 Addition of Corrosion Inhibitor

  Metal corrosion results from the simultaneous occurrence of anodic and cathodic processes in an electrolyte solution. The addition of a corrosion inhibitor can either retard one of these processes or inhibit both, thereby reducing the rate of corrosion. The selection of an appropriate inhibitor depends on specific conditions, such as the salt concentration, pH, dissolved oxygen level, and the presence of interfering substances in the water. Soft water causes only slight corrosion to steel; under these circumstances, even very small doses of inhibitors—such as sodium chromate, sodium nitrite, polyphosphates, sodium benzoate, or borax—are effective. For circulating water with low salinity, corrosion of carbon steel can typically be controlled by adjusting the pH to an alkaline range. Sodium chromate and sodium nitrite are effective inhibitors for steel, but sodium nitrite is unsuitable for copper or brass; for these materials, inhibitors like benzothiazole‑thiol are preferred to suppress corrosion. In waters rich in organic matter, such as seawater, oxidative consumption of inhibitors by organic compounds is substantial, making oxidizing inhibitors like chromates and nitrites impractical. In such cases, organic‑based inhibitors offer superior protection.

  2.6 Electrochemical Protection

  Electrochemical protection methods are categorized into cathodic protection and anodic protection. Cathodic protection involves shifting the metal’s potential in the negative direction, moving it into the passivation region of the E–pH diagram, thereby reducing or suppressing anodic corrosion; this can be achieved either through impressed current or sacrificial anodes. Anodic protection, on the other hand, uses an external power source to polarize the protected metal positively—i.e., to induce anodic polarization—so that its potential enters the passivation region of the E–pH diagram, thus inhibiting corrosion. The uniformity of current distribution in cathodic protection is critical to the quality of protection; the potential at every point on the protected component must reach a level that ensures complete protection. Consequently, the layout of the anodes and the magnitude of the impressed current are key factors in cathodic protection. In addition, when employing cathodic protection, the following two points should be kept in mind: (1) in hydrogen‑evolution corrosion environments characterized by acidic media, cathodic protection consumes substantial electrical energy and may readily lead to hydrogen embrittlement; (2) the protective effect of sacrificial anodes is limited to a finite length near the inlet of heat‑exchanger tubes, and achieving effective cathodic protection deep within the tube remains challenging. At present, small seawater heat exchangers typically rely on sacrificial anode cathodic protection, whereas large heat exchangers generally employ impressed‑current cathodic protection. When using sacrificial anodes, it is also important to note: (1) in environments with high chloride ion concentrations, where chlorides can locally disrupt the passive film and trigger pitting corrosion, anodic protection is generally not advisable; (2) the required equipment is extensive, resulting in higher costs. Zinc is currently the most commonly selected material for sacrificial anodes, though research is also underway exploring magnesium‑based metals and aluminum‑based alloys as alternative sacrificial anode materials.

  3. Prospects for Corrosion Protection Technologies in Seawater Heat Exchangers

  Corrosion failure in seawater heat exchangers can manifest in many forms; therefore, each case must be analyzed individually, with emphasis on identifying the dominant failure mechanisms and implementing appropriate mitigation strategies. Although current seawater heat exchangers incorporate nearly all of the aforementioned corrosion‑prevention measures, none has yet succeeded in fundamentally resolving the issue of corrosion.

  Analysis of the corrosion mechanisms in heat exchangers reveals that electrochemical corrosion and stress corrosion are the primary types of corrosion affecting seawater‑side heat exchangers. Consequently, corrosion protection should focus on two key approaches: electrochemical protection and reduction of the equipment’s stress levels. Regarding electrochemical corrosion, cathodic protection has been successfully implemented on offshore platform heat exchangers abroad. Generally, large heat exchangers employ impressed‑current cathodic protection, while small seawater‑side heat exchangers typically use sacrificial anode cathodic protection, both of which can mitigate corrosion to a certain extent. In the realm of cathodic protection, it is essential to conduct in‑depth studies of the potential distribution across heat‑exchanging components and develop measures to achieve a more uniform potential profile, thereby satisfying passivation requirements and designing highly reliable control systems. As for internal stresses, in addition to the pressure loads experienced by the heat exchanger, factors such as thermal gradients, equipment vibration, fluid‑induced impacts, localized stress concentrations, and residual stresses generated during manufacturing can all give rise to high‑stress regions. The presence of these areas accelerates corrosion. Therefore, it is imperative to address this issue from three perspectives—design, fabrication, and operation—by optimizing the operating environment of the equipment. In the design phase, structural optimization combined with detailed thermo‑mechanical coupled stress analysis can reduce the peak stress magnitude. During fabrication, residual stresses must be rigorously controlled, and in operation, operational parameters should be carefully managed to minimize vibration and excessive fluid‑induced impacts. By undertaking these measures, the service life of the equipment can be effectively extended, leading to substantial improvements in economic performance.

Leave a message or feedback