News Center
News Center
Image Name

NEWS

News Center

Freeze Damage and Anti-Freeze Measures for Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchangers

2014-09-25 10:29

  Shell-and-tube for refrigeration Heat exchanger Accidents frequently occur in which the refrigeration system shuts down due to ruptured heat exchange tubes, resulting in substantial economic losses. One of the most common causes of such tube failures is ice formation on the water side of the heat exchanger: as the ice expands, it can burst or crush the tubes. Condensers and flooded evaporators are typically prone to ice‑induced tube rupture, whereas dry evaporators more often experience ice‑pressure damage to the tubes. The primary reasons for ice formation inside heat exchangers can be summarized as follows:

  1. When a unit is shut down for an extended period and the water has not been drained or has not been completely removed, the water remaining in the heat exchanger tubes will freeze and expand upon ambient temperatures falling below 0°C, ultimately rupturing the tubes. To prevent this, users should ensure that all water is thoroughly drained from the heat exchanger during prolonged shutdowns. Drain valves or drain plugs are provided at the lower ends of the water‑side end caps of condensers and flooded evaporators, as well as at the bottom of dry‑type evaporator casings, allowing maintenance personnel to empty the system through these ports. For air‑source heat pump systems, short shutdowns may occur during winter operation, especially in low‑ambient‑temperature conditions where water temperatures can quickly drop below freezing. However, frequent draining can be cumbersome. For such systems, it is recommended to implement an antifreeze operating mode: when the unit enters shutdown, the antifreeze mode is automatically activated. If the water temperature falls below a set threshold, the control system automatically starts the circulating pump; should the temperature continue to decline, the heating mode is engaged, activating the compressor until the water temperature rises back into a safe range.

  2. During equipment maintenance, if the heat exchanger’s water is not completely drained or the water pump is not turned on to circulate the water before recovering and charging refrigerant, the refrigerant will rapidly evaporate, absorbing heat from the water. Because the water inside the heat exchanger remains stagnant, it quickly freezes, leading to rupture and damage of the heat exchange tubes. To prevent this, maintenance personnel must ensure that refrigerant recovery and charging are performed only when the heat exchanger is either completely drained of water or has circulating water.

  3. Insufficient refrigerant charge or a leak in the refrigeration system can lead to an abnormal evaporator pressure, causing the evaporator temperature to remain below 0°C for extended periods. When the water flow rate within the evaporator is low or when stagnant zones occur, ice formation is likely, potentially resulting in tube rupture due to ice expansion or damage from ice‑induced pressure. To prevent such issues, ensure the refrigeration system is adequately charged with refrigerant and install a low-pressure alarm. Additionally, equip the evaporator outlet with an antifreeze protection switch, and require maintenance personnel to regularly monitor system pressures to promptly detect any refrigerant leaks.

  4. Since the water system is not equipped with a flow‑interrupt protection device, when the pump malfunctions or for other reasons the water flow is suddenly interrupted during equipment operation, the compressor continues to run without sufficient time to reduce its load or shut down. Meanwhile, the refrigerant in the evaporator keeps evaporating, and both the low‑pressure protection and the freeze‑protection devices often fail to respond in time. As a result, the water in the evaporator freezes, leading to rupture and damage of the heat‑exchange tubes. To prevent such incidents, it is essential to install flow switches or differential pressure switches—along with other flow‑interrupt protection devices—in the water system.

  5. Due to malfunctions in the equipment’s sensors or associated protective devices, the system fails to issue timely alarms and shut down when abnormal conditions occur. This is particularly problematic with temperature sensors: if a sensor malfunctions, it may fail to report accurate temperature readings. As a result, even when the actual water temperature has already reached the load‑reduction or shutdown threshold, the sensor‑reported temperature may still remain within the operating or loading range. Consequently, the water temperature can drop sharply, eventually freezing and causing the heat‑exchanger tubes to rupture and become damaged. To mitigate this risk, it is recommended to use high‑precision, reliable water‑outlet temperature sensors and to install an additional frost‑protection sensor or temperature switch, implementing dual safeguards to address potential sensor failures. In addition, equipment maintenance personnel should regularly calibrate the temperature sensors using a thermometer; if any sensor is found to be inaccurate, it should be replaced promptly.

  

 Freeze Damage and Anti-Freeze Measures for Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchangers

Leave a message or feedback